Friday, 27 January 2023

How Indian Healthcare System differs from US

01 March 2022 | Views

We often get asked questions around fundamentals of the healthcare landscape in India. To put the response in context, we have used the US healthcare industry as a benchmark to highlight the landscape in India. The US and India have something in common -a complex mix of public and private healthcare and insurance. This article highlights some of the broad differences between the two healthcare systems and is not meant to be comprehensive in any way

The US healthcare spend dwarfs the Indian healthcare market. The entire GDP of India is $3 trillion; US health care spending alone is $4 trillion. Comparatively; the healthcare spend in India is $ 130-150 billion. The US spends 17 per cent  of its GDP on healthcare, relative to ~4  per cent  that India does. Of this, the public spend on healthcare is 1.3 per cent . In comparison, Europe overall spends 10 per cent  of GDP on healthcare. The per capita annual healthcare expenditure in India is less than $100, while that in the US is over $10000!

Clearly, this is not only because people are consuming more healthcare in the US (which is true), the price tag for healthcare in the US is really high – for example one RTPCR test in the US could cost upwards of $200 whereas in India it is less than $10-15.

The US health infrastructure is ahead of India’s on some of the basic metrics, though India is catching up.

Today, the US is ahead of India in terms of infrastructure available per 1000 people. The number of doctors per 1000 in the US is 2.6, compared to 0.8 in India. India is expected to catch up!

The number of nurses per 1000, at 11.9 in the US, is 8X of that in India. Similarly, the number of beds available per 1000 is 6X in the US, at 2.9 as opposed to 0.5 in India. Both countries lag behind the WHO recommendation of 5 beds per 1000 people.

In India, however, there is a concentration of hospital beds in urban areas and supply demand gap may be lower here. We believe that these metrics in India are certainly moving in the right direction. For example, the number of medical colleges and graduating doctors has increased by 17 per cent , which is bound to close this gap to some extent. We also saw a large number of mobilisation of resources at every level in India during COVID, which gives us confidence that both the private sector and the government are working much more aggressively to increase the infrastructure accessibility in the healthcare sector.

 

Innovative disruptive models  

A major difference is in the spending pools in the countries. While out of pocket expenses on health are only 10 per cent  in the US, the number is a staggering 65 per cent  in India, because of the low penetration of public and private insurance. Additionally, while the US allows for OPD coverage under insurance, in India, this has a negligible share. However, we must also highlight that the cost to insure a family of 4 is ~$ 21K, which is 70 times more expensive than that in India.

The existence of higher insurance penetration has historically allowed for the adoption of a larger number of innovative models in the US, especially in domains such as healthcare delivery and devices and diagnostics. One example we can highlight is that of the growing mental health market. As it is insurance covered, the size of the market is $ 50B in the US, much larger than that in India.

 

India remains leader in generics 

The US pharma industry is the largest in the world, with a market size of ~$ 500 billion! In comparison, the Indian pharma market stands at ~$20- 30 billion. US pharma companies spend an average of 20-22 per cent  on R&D whereas this number is closer to 8 per cent  for Indian pharma companies. US companies are much more focused on newer drug development (~4500 drugs under development in the US compared to less than a dozen in India).

India is considered to be the ‘generic pharmacy of the world’. It is the largest producer of generic pharmaceuticals globally with a 20 per cent  of the market share. While generic drugs are 90-95 per cent  in both US and India by volume, by value the number is about 10-15 per cent  in the US, compared to 95 per cent  in India.

There are also differences in the pharma distribution market in both geographies. The US is largely organised with the top three distributors controlling 90 per cent  of the market, in India, by comparison the top 3 distributors have a miniscule share of <5 per cent . In the US, the top 15 pharmacies control 55 per cent  of the market, whereas India has 800K pharmacies, most of which are independently owned. The top 15 only occupy <2 per cent  of the market, leaving scope for organisation and eventual consolidation in the industry. With consolidation, there will be better negotiation, standardised distribution and cost efficiencies.

 

Caps on drug prices 

In India, approx. 14 per cent  of drugs by value and 25 per cent  of drugs by volume fall under price controls. This is an important step taken by the government to control healthcare expenses. A little over half of the largely out-of-pocket healthcare expenses are on medicines alone.

Since the US is largely insurance driven, drug prices often get negotiated by the insurers. However, surveys suggest that 79 per cent  of Americans consider US prescription drugs to be highly unaffordable and 30 per cent  in fact go without prescribed medications because of cost. The US government has begun taking some measures to put curbs on drug prices, but several other measures are needed along the way.

Indian medical device seems a tiny drop compared to the US, but with the constant push and quality talent, is expected to dominate the markets

The US med-tech industry is also the largest globally, with a market size of $ 150B! The Indian market is estimated to be a  $7-8 billion industry. Given it’s a comparatively small and fast growing market in India, the projected CAGR for Indian med-tech ~13 per cent  is expectedly 2.5X that of the US. Currently India relies heavily on imports for its medical devices. However, young talent with strong R&D capabilities, availability of low-cost infrastructure and a government push for ‘Make in India’ is creating vast opportunities for growth in this sector.

In conclusion, we do believe that the US is a large healthcare market on account of high prices for procedures and drugs which need to be brought down. However, the US is also very innovative and organised and we believe India is headed in the same direction. New age companies that address unmet needs in India and have the potential to disrupt US markets as well are better positioned to bring efficiency and reduce costs in the US. While India lags behind in size compared to the US in healthcare spending, the market is fast growing and has seen high disruption over the past few years.

There are several tailwinds for growth- increased expenditure by the government, disruptive digital technologies/business models leapfrogging years of infrastructure investments in the US. The startup investments in healthcare alone have grown 3X in 5 years, and the change is reflected in public markets too! The make-up of the exchange, which was dominated by pharma, is seeing tremendous change as companies across various sub-sectors are getting listed. Being a VC focused on new age companies we are enthusiastic about the opportunities in the Indian healthcare ecosystem.

 

Alka Goel, Founding Partner, Alkemi Growth Capital 

Comments

× Your session has been expired. Please click here to Sign-in or Sign-up
   New User? Create Account